Multiple credible sources point to a 44% gap, with Redfin as the primary data origin. Redfin’s market analysis explicitly states that America had 44% more home sellers than buyers, and major outlets (including the New York Times, Yahoo Finance, and Scotsman Guide) report the same figure, attributing it to Redfin’s dataset. The evidence is consistent and specific, typically referring to a recent monthly snapshot (January) at the national level. There are no credible contradictions in the provided materials. The main caveat is that the figure is time-bound and derived from Redfin’s proprietary methodology rather than an official government statistic, so it should be interpreted as a recent, Redfin-measured national snapshot rather than a permanent or universally defined condition.